Lies of P - Records

There are 16 Records in the game, and you need them all to unlock this trophy. 6 are tied to NG+, so you can't get them in a single playthrough, plus some are obtained bay lying, some by telling the truth - and since you play either Lie or Truth playthrough, it will be impossible to get even the regular 10 on your first run.

List of Records

• Feel: Inside the House on Elysion Boulevard (Chapter 2 - before the elite with police button fight, the same area) - Complete sidequest Weeping Woman. Give her Broken Baby Puppet found in Krat City Hall, and say "That’s a cute baby" to lie if you're playing lie playthrough. Some people say that this can only be obtained on your Lie playthrough.
• Divine Service: St. Frangelico Cathedral Library (Chapter 4) - Talk to Cecile when you arrive at this location, and then collect Holy Mark in the same location. You need to find that and return to Cecile before fighting the Archbishop, otherwise you will miss out on the record. After you do all of that, and defeat the Archbishop, return to Cecile and pick up the items
• Someday: Malum District (Chapter 5) - Buy from the Wandering Merchant inside the Red Lobster Inn for 3,800 Ergo.
• Fascination: Estella Opera House Entrance (Chapter 5) - Give Adelina the Red Apple before defeating the King of Puppets main boss. You can buy the apple from Polendina for 1,000 Ergo in Hotel Krat. Adelina can be found if you follow the path up and to the right main stairs when you enter the Opera House. At the end of one of the hallways on the top floor are the doors and Adeline is inside. On the opposite side of the hallway is the chest.
• Quixotic: Grand Exhibition Conference Room (Chapter 7) - After defeating Champion Victor at the end of the chapter, continue on and you’ll eventually reunite with the Red Fox and Black Cat NPC's. Agree to give them some Gold Coin Fruit (they will ask for 1 piece) to receive this Record.
• Why: Hotel Krat (Chapter 7) - Find Belle during Chapter 8 in Grand Exhibition Gallery and talk to her after defeating Champion Victor. At the end of Chapter 8 or beginning of Chapter 9 you can talk to her to unlock her quest. Find the NPC she's looking for in Krat Central Station and return to her. You need to lie - say that he died in the battle. That will give you the record.
• Misty E’rA: Hermit's Cave (Chapter 9) - Kill Alidoro to get Alidoro’s Cryptic Vessel. Decrypt it, read it (all pages) and talk to Eugenie. If you say "I think he was just a talented Stalker" it means you will Lie and that will give you the record. You can either get this one or Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1 during a single playthrough
• Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1: Kill Alidoro to get Alidoro’s Cryptic Vessel. Decrypt it, read it (all pages) and talk to Eugenie. If you say "He was Eugénie’s older brother" it means you will tell the Truth and that will give you the record. You can either get this one or Misty E’rA during a single playthrough
• Memory of Beach: Ascension Bridge (Chapter 11) - After defeating Laxasia boss, return to Geppetto's Study and inspect Antonia's wheelchair
• Shadow Flower: After defeating Laxasia The Complete, enter Sophia’s bedroom and choose “Give her peace”. This is part of Lie playthrough and can only be obtainable by telling her that lie.

List of NG+ Records

• Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1 (Golden): Buy from Wandering Merchant near the Cerasani Alley stargazer, before the Parade Master main boss, and buy the Record for 6,000 Ergo. Wandering Merchant dissapears later so make sure to buy from him on your first visits
• Quixotic (Golden): Buy from Wandering Merchant in Inside the House on Elysion Boulevard area during Chapter 2
• Shadow Flower (Golden): Buy from Wandering Merchant in Lorenzini Arcade area during Chapter 7
• Memory of Beach (Golden): Buy from Wandering Merchant in Abandoned Apartment area during Chapter 9
• Proposal, Flower, Wolf Part 1: Kill Alidoro to get Alidoro’s Cryptic Vessel. Decrypt it, read it (all pages) and talk to Eugenie. If you say "He was Eugénie’s older brother" it means you will tell the Truth and that will give you the record. I'm mentioning this here because this whole guide is based on your first playthrough as a Lie playthrough
• Fascination (Golden): Buy from Test Subject 826 in Rosa Isabelle Street Entrance during Chapter 11. You must first find this NPC in Arche Abbey Outer Wall, talk to him, defeat Laxasia, and then find him in Rosa Isabelle Street Entrance (run towards the bottom of the stairs and towards the burning fence, left through the shorcut, and on the bridge that leads above the Clown fight.